After more than seven months, Pi reaches land. Richard Parker disappears into the forest immediately. Why no goodbyes ("Well, wild animals do not have the capacity to say goodbye" is not the type of answer we are looking for)?
When they reach land, no goodbyes between Richard Parker and Pi is hard to deal with because all that they went through. They were out to sea for so long and eventhough one is an animal and one is a human, a bond still formed between them. "I owe you more gratitiude than I can express. I couldn't have done it without you" (Martel 286). The fact that Pi is expressing his feelings showing that he ended up really caring for the tiger is a big deal. Pi was terrified of him in the beginning and learned to deal with him over time and needed him in order to survive. When he runs away and does not look back at Pi, is it disheartening for Pi just to blow it off and use the excuse the Richard Parker is an animal so he can not say goodbye. With the bond that they had and what they went through together in order to survive was huge and deserves a better goodbye.
When Pi and Richard Parker finally reach land and the tiger runs off, it leaves Pi very upset and distraught. Richard Parker most likely did not say goodbye cause he figured it would be the same situation when they first landed on an island. Richard Parker would explore, hunt for food, and look for a mate, and then return to the lifeboat at the end of the day where Pi would be waiting. Richard Parker did not know they had finally reached salvation, and did not mean to hurt the long relationship Pi and him had built for so long. -Calypso
The sad truth is that as much as Pi loved Richard Parker in the end, he stil remained an animal that does not have the capacity to feel human emotion. He is wild and has a mindset of an animal even though he shared such a long time and what seemed to be a connection between Pi. Pi is a smart person, but since he was so vulnerable during these seven months it is heart breaking for him that Richard Parker just ran away.
AFter being in a lifeboat for seven months, Richard Parker and Pi had a bond. Because Richard lived in the zoo for so long, he needed Pi to provide for him, because that is what he was used to. This helped Pi stay alive. When they finally reached land, Pi was afraid to get out at first but Richard Parker was ready to get out. "At the edge of the jungle, he stopped. I was certain he would turn my way. He would lok at me. He would flaten his ears. He would growl. In some such way, he would conclude our relationship. He did nothing of the sort" (Martel 284). Pi was sure that Richard would show him how much he means to him, because they were on the boat so long. However, Richard did not. Animals feel attachment, but not the same sort of attachment as people do. It was obvious that Pi felt strongly towards this tiger, because this tiger had kept him alive. However, to Richard, Pi was jsut another person who did the same thing that any other person had done for him: cleaned up after him, fed him, gave him water, and make sure he was safe. To Richard, the jungle, was something he needed to find, and tigers, especially are very territorial, so as soon as he sees it, he knows he must go to it, and Pi, from that moment on, was in his past.
No goodbyes were said because after being in a boat for seven months a human and even an animal when they see land all they want to do is go and be free. Richard Parker saw land and immediatly his animal instincts kicked in and he had to be free, since his life before he was in a zoo. Pi on the other hand knows how to express emotion and feels like Richard Parker saved his life and gave him a reason to live so without a doubt Pi would feel like he needs to say goodbye to Richard Parker to end that part of his life and move on to a new part of his life. -Athena
Pi formed a relationship with Richard Parker after having to live with him on the lifeboat for so long. For Pi, Richard Parker was part of the reason that he survived. He said that he owed his survival to Richard Parker. To Richard Parker, Pi was just a provider. He was the one that gave him food and water. Although this seems like it would make Pi a special person to Richard Parker, it did not. Richard Parker had lived his entire life in the zoo being taken care of by the workers. Although the situation was different, the dynamic was the same that a man provided for Richard Parker. Once they landed, there was no need to say goodbye for him. He was just going into the wild to continue on with his life, not realizing how significant the journey was for Pi.
Goodbyes can often be more painful than just having someone walk away. Lingering around to say goodbye to Pi with have made it harder for Pi to let go. Pi had already become attached to Richard Parker. Richard Parker however was able to realize that they both had to move on. Pi would have wanted them to stay together and in doing that they would have been holding on to the past. They were forced to live the same lifestyle because of their situation but in all reality, they couldn't continue living that way. It would have become impossible in civilization.
Richard Parker did not have the feelings for Pi that Pi held for him. In the end, no matter what they all went through, Richard Parker was just and animal who lived by insticts alone. As much as Pi wanted to say goodbye to him, Richard was just a savage being in his life who needed to leave Pi for good. By losing this companion PI has rid himself of the savage aspects that have been haunting him for so many months at sea.
Goodbye are often sad and depressing. Therefore people have a hard time to do that. However, Pi goes on to say in the story " I owe you more graditute than i can express" (martee 206) So honestly Pi is the one say thankyou and goodbye because the animals didnt eat him. Also animals are nor exactly like humans. So there goddbye are not as important as there hellos.
Richard Parker probably realized that he surved his purpose while on the boat. I think he knew that he owed Pi for saving his life, so gave him the courtesy of not eating him. Then once they were on dry land, he was free to go his way as Pi was. Honey Dew however makes a good point. It is true that Richard Parker doesn't have it in him to return the same sentimental human feelings that Pi has. To him, he has done what he could for Pi and leaving without a word would make the separation easier for Pi.
There were no goodbyes because wild animals are simply incapable of emotional bonds in which the can show appreciation unless reciprocating an immediate deed. When Richard Parker ran in to the forest he had no intention of pleasing or displeasing Pi. He simply let his natural instinct kick in and acted as any other wild land animal coupled up on a boat in the middle of the ocean for an extended period of time would have, he returned to what he knew; the land.
When Richard Parker and Pi finally reach Mexico, Richard Parker goes straight for the forest with no goodbyes. This upsets Pi because he became close to Richard Parker over the last seven months. What Pi fails to realize is that Richard Parker is not a human, feeling human emotions. Although Pi was treating Richard Parker like a human friend on the ship, he is just an animal. Richard Parker was happy to be on land and he took advantage of that.
Richard Parker's run off left Pi very distraught. Richard Parker's animal insticts probably told him to kill Pi for food. Richard Parker could have grown an emotional attachment to Pi and did not want to eat him, so he ran off before his body could tell him to kill him.
Even though Pi thought of Richard Parker as a true friend, companion throughout the whole ordeal, it was obvious that Richard Parker was not clear of the outcome. He must have assumed that it was just like the pervious island where he could go off and play, and at the end of the day, he would return to the boat. However, this time will be different because Pi will not be there at the end of the day. Richard Parker will have to realize that Pi has 'left' him and he will probably end in the forest. I don' think that Richard Parker realized that this was the end for him and Pi.
I believe that somewhere in Richard Parker's animal mind he must have felt some respect or care for Pi. However, animals must follow their natural instincts, especially in an unfamilar territory where they only have their senses to fall back on. When Richard Parker saw the unfamilar territory of land, all he saw was the jungle and knew he needed to be there. He may have thought he would see Pi again, but afterall he is a tiger.
When Rishard Parker and Pi reach land, Richard Parker runs off into the wilderness without saying "good bye". Pi is upset that he did not have the opportunity to give the final farewell to Parker. When humans loose a family member or if someone loved is moving away usually there are feelings and those feelings are very important. When animals lose family members they usually just go off and wither join another family or try to live on their own. Eventhough Rishard Parker and Pi had a good relationship at the time Richard Parker did not care and just wanted to be free and run off. -Leonardo
Richad Parker does not have as strong of a connection as Pi does to him. In the wild aniamls are rarley upset when a relativy dies unless it deals with a mother and her young. Richard sees Pi as someone who provides him with food and helps him before he is able to go back into the wild. He believes he has no one to really say good bye to.
When Pie realizes that Richard Parker is gone and he will never see him again he is obviously upset. This had been the only creature that he had reacted with for almost a year so he had obviously grown attached to him. The animal was probably to exited to be free that he was probably not even concerned with Pie. He may have also wanted to escape the control which Pie had been forcing over him through his taming procedures.
There were no goodbyes said between Richard Parker and Pi because goodbyes are often very depressing. While they were happy that their time on the boat had come to an end, they were also sad that their time had come to an end. Because they were on the boat for so long they had created a bond. Richard Parker had been in captivity since he was a cub and being taken care of was all that he knew. He probably felt that it was time for him to be on his own, and could not find a way to thank Pi for all that he had done so he just ran away. Pi was upset when Richard Parker ran away because Pi wanted to thank him for helping take his mind off of their situation and helping keep him alive.
Richad Parker does not have as strong of a connection as Pi does to him. In the wild aniamls are rarley upset when a relativy dies unless it deals with a mother and her young. Richard sees Pi as someone who provides him with food and helps him before he is able to go back into the wild. He believes he has no one to really say good bye to. Richard wants to live on his own and hurt be left alone and he feels he can't do so if he has a connection to Pi -Squirtle
The relationship between Pi and richard parker, isnt mutual. Pi respect richard out of fear of his own life not because he truely cares. Richard parker only views Pi as a zoo keeper, providing food, cleaning after him, and keeping him company. For Richard Parker, their relationship is the same as anyone else who has ever been responsilbe for his well being at the zoo. so in the end, when it comes to say goodbye, theres no real point to it, richard parker wouldnt say goodbye to his zoo keeper as he escaped from his cage, then why would he now. - Mclovin
There are no goodbyes from Richard Parker when they reach land for a couple reasons. First, after everything they went through, Richard Parker just wanted to get back to the life he once led being a wild tiger in the jugle. Also, Richard Parker is a tiger and thus is not physically abvle to say goodbye. However, I believe that simpily by not eating Pi, that was enough "goodbye" for him. -ZEUS
When Richard Parker runs away from pi as soon as they hit shore Pi is sure that Richard Parker will in some way say goodbye. "At the edge of the jungle, he stopped. I was certain he would turn my way. He would lok at me. He would flaten his ears. He would growl. In some such way, he would conclude our relationship. He did nothing of the sort" (Martel 284). Instead he recieves nothing and he is hurt. The only reason that there would be no goodbyes is just because Richard Parker was acting off of instinct and getting himself to safety. Foxtrot
I believe that the reason Richard Parker did not turn around to say good-bye is because Richard Parker is the animal instinct of Pi. Pi had reached Mexico, and in as much, Richard Parker returns to the jungle of life very much as does Pi. Richard Parker returns to his natural state as will Pi. There is no good-bye because Richard Parker has not really left, rather that animal instinct is hidden within Pi until the proper time, if ever, that he needs it to resurface.
24 comments:
When they reach land, no goodbyes between Richard Parker and Pi is hard to deal with because all that they went through. They were out to sea for so long and eventhough one is an animal and one is a human, a bond still formed between them. "I owe you more gratitiude than I can express. I couldn't have done it without you" (Martel 286). The fact that Pi is expressing his feelings showing that he ended up really caring for the tiger is a big deal. Pi was terrified of him in the beginning and learned to deal with him over time and needed him in order to survive. When he runs away and does not look back at Pi, is it disheartening for Pi just to blow it off and use the excuse the Richard Parker is an animal so he can not say goodbye. With the bond that they had and what they went through together in order to survive was huge and deserves a better goodbye.
When Pi and Richard Parker finally reach land and the tiger runs off, it leaves Pi very upset and distraught. Richard Parker most likely did not say goodbye cause he figured it would be the same situation when they first landed on an island. Richard Parker would explore, hunt for food, and look for a mate, and then return to the lifeboat at the end of the day where Pi would be waiting. Richard Parker did not know they had finally reached salvation, and did not mean to hurt the long relationship Pi and him had built for so long.
-Calypso
The sad truth is that as much as Pi loved Richard Parker in the end, he stil remained an animal that does not have the capacity to feel human emotion. He is wild and has a mindset of an animal even though he shared such a long time and what seemed to be a connection between Pi. Pi is a smart person, but since he was so vulnerable during these seven months it is heart breaking for him that Richard Parker just ran away.
AFter being in a lifeboat for seven months, Richard Parker and Pi had a bond. Because Richard lived in the zoo for so long, he needed Pi to provide for him, because that is what he was used to. This helped Pi stay alive. When they finally reached land, Pi was afraid to get out at first but Richard Parker was ready to get out. "At the edge of the jungle, he stopped. I was certain he would turn my way. He would lok at me. He would flaten his ears. He would growl. In some such way, he would conclude our relationship. He did nothing of the sort" (Martel 284). Pi was sure that Richard would show him how much he means to him, because they were on the boat so long. However, Richard did not. Animals feel attachment, but not the same sort of attachment as people do. It was obvious that Pi felt strongly towards this tiger, because this tiger had kept him alive. However, to Richard, Pi was jsut another person who did the same thing that any other person had done for him: cleaned up after him, fed him, gave him water, and make sure he was safe. To Richard, the jungle, was something he needed to find, and tigers, especially are very territorial, so as soon as he sees it, he knows he must go to it, and Pi, from that moment on, was in his past.
No goodbyes were said because after being in a boat for seven months a human and even an animal when they see land all they want to do is go and be free. Richard Parker saw land and immediatly his animal instincts kicked in and he had to be free, since his life before he was in a zoo. Pi on the other hand knows how to express emotion and feels like Richard Parker saved his life and gave him a reason to live so without a doubt Pi would feel like he needs to say goodbye to Richard Parker to end that part of his life and move on to a new part of his life.
-Athena
Pi formed a relationship with Richard Parker after having to live with him on the lifeboat for so long. For Pi, Richard Parker was part of the reason that he survived. He said that he owed his survival to Richard Parker. To Richard Parker, Pi was just a provider. He was the one that gave him food and water. Although this seems like it would make Pi a special person to Richard Parker, it did not. Richard Parker had lived his entire life in the zoo being taken care of by the workers. Although the situation was different, the dynamic was the same that a man provided for Richard Parker. Once they landed, there was no need to say goodbye for him. He was just going into the wild to continue on with his life, not realizing how significant the journey was for Pi.
Goodbyes can often be more painful than just having someone walk away. Lingering around to say goodbye to Pi with have made it harder for Pi to let go. Pi had already become attached to Richard Parker. Richard Parker however was able to realize that they both had to move on. Pi would have wanted them to stay together and in doing that they would have been holding on to the past. They were forced to live the same lifestyle because of their situation but in all reality, they couldn't continue living that way. It would have become impossible in civilization.
Richard Parker did not have the feelings for Pi that Pi held for him. In the end, no matter what they all went through, Richard Parker was just and animal who lived by insticts alone. As much as Pi wanted to say goodbye to him, Richard was just a savage being in his life who needed to leave Pi for good. By losing this companion PI has rid himself of the savage aspects that have been haunting him for so many months at sea.
Goodbye are often sad and depressing. Therefore people have a hard time to do that. However, Pi goes on to say in the story " I owe you more graditute than i can express" (martee 206) So honestly Pi is the one say thankyou and goodbye because the animals didnt eat him. Also animals are nor exactly like humans. So there goddbye are not as important as there hellos.
Richard Parker probably realized that he surved his purpose while on the boat. I think he knew that he owed Pi for saving his life, so gave him the courtesy of not eating him. Then once they were on dry land, he was free to go his way as Pi was. Honey Dew however makes a good point. It is true that Richard Parker doesn't have it in him to return the same sentimental human feelings that Pi has. To him, he has done what he could for Pi and leaving without a word would make the separation easier for Pi.
There were no goodbyes because wild animals are simply incapable of emotional bonds in which the can show appreciation unless reciprocating an immediate deed. When Richard Parker ran in to the forest he had no intention of pleasing or displeasing Pi. He simply let his natural instinct kick in and acted as any other wild land animal coupled up on a boat in the middle of the ocean for an extended period of time would have, he returned to what he knew; the land.
When Richard Parker and Pi finally reach Mexico, Richard Parker goes straight for the forest with no goodbyes. This upsets Pi because he became close to Richard Parker over the last seven months. What Pi fails to realize is that Richard Parker is not a human, feeling human emotions. Although Pi was treating Richard Parker like a human friend on the ship, he is just an animal. Richard Parker was happy to be on land and he took advantage of that.
Richard Parker's run off left Pi very distraught. Richard Parker's animal insticts probably told him to kill Pi for food. Richard Parker could have grown an emotional attachment to Pi and did not want to eat him, so he ran off before his body could tell him to kill him.
Even though Pi thought of Richard Parker as a true friend, companion throughout the whole ordeal, it was obvious that Richard Parker was not clear of the outcome. He must have assumed that it was just like the pervious island where he could go off and play, and at the end of the day, he would return to the boat. However, this time will be different because Pi will not be there at the end of the day. Richard Parker will have to realize that Pi has 'left' him and he will probably end in the forest. I don' think that Richard Parker realized that this was the end for him and Pi.
I believe that somewhere in Richard Parker's animal mind he must have felt some respect or care for Pi. However, animals must follow their natural instincts, especially in an unfamilar territory where they only have their senses to fall back on. When Richard Parker saw the unfamilar territory of land, all he saw was the jungle and knew he needed to be there. He may have thought he would see Pi again, but afterall he is a tiger.
When Rishard Parker and Pi reach land, Richard Parker runs off into the wilderness without saying "good bye". Pi is upset that he did not have the opportunity to give the final farewell to Parker. When humans loose a family member or if someone loved is moving away usually there are feelings and those feelings are very important. When animals lose family members they usually just go off and wither join another family or try to live on their own. Eventhough Rishard Parker and Pi had a good relationship at the time Richard Parker did not care and just wanted to be free and run off.
-Leonardo
Richad Parker does not have as strong of a connection as Pi does to him. In the wild aniamls are rarley upset when a relativy dies unless it deals with a mother and her young. Richard sees Pi as someone who provides him with food and helps him before he is able to go back into the wild. He believes he has no one to really say good bye to.
When Pie realizes that Richard Parker is gone and he will never see him again he is obviously upset. This had been the only creature that he had reacted with for almost a year so he had obviously grown attached to him. The animal was probably to exited to be free that he was probably not even concerned with Pie. He may have also wanted to escape the control which Pie had been forcing over him through his taming procedures.
There were no goodbyes said between Richard Parker and Pi because goodbyes are often very depressing. While they were happy that their time on the boat had come to an end, they were also sad that their time had come to an end. Because they were on the boat for so long they had created a bond. Richard Parker had been in captivity since he was a cub and being taken care of was all that he knew. He probably felt that it was time for him to be on his own, and could not find a way to thank Pi for all that he had done so he just ran away. Pi was upset when Richard Parker ran away because Pi wanted to thank him for helping take his mind off of their situation and helping keep him alive.
Richad Parker does not have as strong of a connection as Pi does to him. In the wild aniamls are rarley upset when a relativy dies unless it deals with a mother and her young. Richard sees Pi as someone who provides him with food and helps him before he is able to go back into the wild. He believes he has no one to really say good bye to. Richard wants to live on his own and hurt be left alone and he feels he can't do so if he has a connection to Pi -Squirtle
The relationship between Pi and richard parker, isnt mutual. Pi respect richard out of fear of his own life not because he truely cares. Richard parker only views Pi as a zoo keeper, providing food, cleaning after him, and keeping him company. For Richard Parker, their relationship is the same as anyone else who has ever been responsilbe for his well being at the zoo. so in the end, when it comes to say goodbye, theres no real point to it, richard parker wouldnt say goodbye to his zoo keeper as he escaped from his cage, then why would he now.
- Mclovin
There are no goodbyes from Richard Parker when they reach land for a couple reasons. First, after everything they went through, Richard Parker just wanted to get back to the life he once led being a wild tiger in the jugle. Also, Richard Parker is a tiger and thus is not physically abvle to say goodbye. However, I believe that simpily by not eating Pi, that was enough "goodbye" for him.
-ZEUS
When Richard Parker runs away from pi as soon as they hit shore Pi is sure that Richard Parker will in some way say goodbye. "At the edge of the jungle, he stopped. I was certain he would turn my way. He would lok at me. He would flaten his ears. He would growl. In some such way, he would conclude our relationship. He did nothing of the sort" (Martel 284). Instead he recieves nothing and he is hurt. The only reason that there would be no goodbyes is just because Richard Parker was acting off of instinct and getting himself to safety.
Foxtrot
I believe that the reason Richard Parker did not turn around to say good-bye is because Richard Parker is the animal instinct of Pi. Pi had reached Mexico, and in as much, Richard Parker returns to the jungle of life very much as does Pi. Richard Parker returns to his natural state as will Pi. There is no good-bye because Richard Parker has not really left, rather that animal instinct is hidden within Pi until the proper time, if ever, that he needs it to resurface.
Post a Comment